Which SIPs for roof: 10 1/2 in. vs. 12 1/2 in. for performance?
We’ve been quoted an additional $1,460 to “upgrade” to 12.5-inch roof SIPs and are wondering if the additional investment is “worth it.”
I’ve always heard that the more insulation you have in your ceiling/attic, the better, but I’m wondering if that $1,450 would be better spent on other energy-efficiency measures.
Thanks,
Claire
GBA Detail Library
A collection of one thousand construction details organized by climate and house part
Replies
Claire,
It's certainly true that "the more insulation you have in your ceiling/attic, the better."
Whether the upgrade is a cost-effective investment depends on your climate and the cost of alternative measures. A HERS rater or energy consultant should be able to help you optimize your investments in your building envelope and HVAC system.
You will get better advice if you tell us where you are building.
Hi Martin ~
We're building in the Applegate Valley of southern Oregon, latitude 42.26; longitude -123.19, elev. 1,480 ft.
Here's a quick HDD analysis:
Description: Farenheit-based heating degree days for a base temperature of 65F
Source: http://www.degreedays.net (using temperature data from http://www.wunderground.com)
Accuracy: No problems detected
Station: Sorensen's Ranch, Applegate, OR, US
Station ID: KORGRANT8
Month starting HDD
8/1/08 108
9/1/08 192
10/1/08 409
11/1/08 595
12/1/08 889
1/1/09 850
2/1/09 668
3/1/09 652
4/1/09 544
5/1/09 324
6/1/09 151
7/1/09 147
8/1/09 298
Description: Farenheit-based cooling degree days for a base temperature of 65F
Source: http://www.degreedays.net (using temperature data from http://www.wunderground.com)
Accuracy: No problems detected
Station: Sorensen's Ranch, Applegate, OR, US
Station ID: KORGRANT8
Month starting CDD
8/1/08 245
9/1/08 175
10/1/08 37
11/1/08 0
12/1/08 0
1/1/09 0
2/1/09 0
3/1/09 4
4/1/09 32
5/1/09 105
6/1/09 122
7/1/09 338
8/1/09 249
Thanks,
Claire