Minisplits: Wall-Mounted vs. Ceiling Cassette
I have an open 20’x30′ floor plan and looking at a mini-split. (11ft exposed ceilings, Zone 2B, poor-ish insulation).
Working on load calculations now, but I have a general question about unit types:
Aesthetically, a centrally mounted (exposed) ceiling cassette would work the best with my industrial theme, but I’ve noticed several manufactures make high SEER systems that are floor/wall mount only (e.g. Mitsubishi M-Series and Fujitsu LZAS). Also, it would be easier to install as I would have to do much less sheetrock work.
Leaning Mitsubishi and my guess at the moment would be 12k, so an example comparison would be MZ-KJ12NA vs SL-KF12NA
I realize I need to finish my calculations before I can do a real performance comparison, but unless I’m missing something, I’ll likely comedown to aesthetics vs a bit of efficiency?
GBA Detail Library
A collection of one thousand construction details organized by climate and house part
Replies
Joe, the disadvantages of ceiling cassettes are that they require a full 22 1/2" clear space, they need an access panel adjacent to the unit for maintenance, and they are not quite as efficient as wall-mounted units. With wall-mounted units you can direct the vanes to bounce air across the ceiling (the Coanda effect) which can help heat a room evenly; with ceiling-mounted units you don't have that option, but in an air-sealed, well-insulated house it shouldn't matter, and in a zone as warm as yours it's probably not important either. Personally I don't think they're much better-looking than wall-mounted units either, but taste is subjective.
Interesting. Wouldn’t heating the ceiling leave cold air on the floor? I ask because have mistubishi units mounted high on the wall and my contractor said to point the vanes straight down when heating.
Thanks for the info about the Coanda effect. So basically, for the same compressor, circulation/operating pressure is the key differentiator?
I know the Fujutsu LZAS and Mitsubishi M-series also have very low min BTU which helps SEER as well, just not sure why they don't support ceiling cassettes with those compressors
Drafthunter, it depends on several factors, but the idea--which I learned from Cramer Silkworth, a mechanical engineer who trained me in Passive House design and sometimes posts here--is that vanes directed toward the ceiling will allow the heated air to "skip" along the ceiling, leading to evenly heated air. It works best in well-insulated and air-sealed buildings which have little temperature stratification, the term for warm air's tendency to rise. (It's a myth that "heat rises;" heat goes to where there isn't any, but warm, moist air is more buoyant than cool, dry air.)
Others are probably more knowledgeable about the finer details than I am. Hopefully someone else weighs in.
There are one way and two way ceiling mounted cassettes that are better looking and narrower than the 4 way ones. Check out MLZ-KP12NA.
If you have rooms in the place, there are also units that support jumper ducts to supply other spaces like:
https://ashp.neep.org/#!/product/28903
The knockouts on the side are for ducts, you can divert up to 50% of the flow to these, just take care as there is very little pressure available, so they must be large and mostly straight.
A ductless mini-split with simple jumper ducts is a very interesting idea and also one that I had never heard of before. Can you point me to where I can read up more on this topic?
I spent some time today trying to track down details on this but came up entirely empty. Even the LG LCN187HV docs that I could find make no mention of jump ducts. Yes, those absolutely do look like punch-out blocks but the PDFs I found never labeled them as such.
So how would I find what units supported jump ducts? And are there docs on how these work?
LG documentation is not the easiest to find, the one time I went down the rabbit hole with these, the only mention I found was that it was for distrubuting air within the same room and 1/2 the unit's flow. No other data.
Search for "branch duct" here:
https://files.lghvac.com/resources/EM_MultiV_CeilingCassette_IndoorUnits.pdf