Mitsubishi mini split behaving very differently with external thermostat vs. without
I am able to monitor my home’s electricity use and I always thought it was a little weird that my Mitsubishi FE18NA heat pump seemed to constantly be spiking up and down, considering that the whole idea of the inverter-driven compressor is that it can run smooth and steady… fast forward to yesterday when I received my MHK1 thermostat and hooked it up. Suddenly, the power usage was steady as a rock.
The real reason I bought the thermostat was because the temperature sensor internal to the heat pump seems to be very inaccurate and we constantly had to tweak the set point on the remote when the outdoor temperature changed. The thermostat also fixed that issue, as now the heat pump can sense the real temperature in the room. This makes me think that perhaps the hot air from the heat pump was pooling around it, causing it to think the room was warmer than it really was, throttling down, until the air dissipated and it realized that it needed to heat again.
Can it really be so flawed by default?
The room it’s in is a small dining room, about 8×10 or so, but one side of this room is totally open to the living room, and the air flow of the heat pump shoots straight down a hallway to the bedrooms. The house does all stay pretty evenly heated, at least with doors left open. Other than having to fiddle with the set point, we’ve never had a comfort problem. The thermostat is actually sitting on a table just a few feet from the heat pump. But maybe those few feet make the difference, particularly not being stuck up by the ceiling in perhaps a pool of warm air.
Two screenshots are attached of the “lumpy” and “not lumpy” power use charts. The small lumps in the “not lumpy” are from the fridge, I believe.
GBA Detail Library
A collection of one thousand construction details organized by climate and house part
Replies
I don't have the sort of real time data you do but my unit feels similar. While I set the unit to 18 degrees C, the actual room temperature is closer to 16 and it seems to satisfy itself before the room gets warm enough. When I run a portable fan in front of the unit to move air elsewhere in my room it runs longer. My Fujitsu does seem to have a second thermometer built into the remote, so I've been putting that in a cooler area when I want it to run a bit more.
We are spending our first winter in our new house, located in NH and heated by one Mitsubishi FH12NA. House specs are at least "pretty good house" and 1320 sq ft of conditioned space.
I've been wondering about the performance and proper settings of the unit. When the remote is set at 70 F, I've found the rooms stay around 64-66 F, depending on whether it's an outlying room or more central open room. I did measure 68 F higher up near the unit.
I don't have electricity monitoring like you do, but I'm wondering if we are experiencing the same thing, at least from the perspective of the built in thermostat not being a good way to maintain a desired temperature.
I'd be curious what others with a single mini split in a high performance house do for temperature settings.
This is interesting, I generally rely on mine for AC, but have figured out that leaving them to their own devices does not always work well, playing with fan speed and vane direction to get the results you want has been my strategy, but an external thermostat sounds like it may be the thing
Nick,
Thanks very much for posting your observation and question here. It's an interesting observation, for sure.
I had a brief exchange of e-mails with Marc Rosenbaum on this topic. Marc said that he doesn't want to go on the record with any theories without knowing more about your installation details, and that he is unfortunately too busy now to get deeply involved.
I'm not going to attribute these hunches to Marc, but a few ideas were tossed around in our exchange. One possibility is that the behavior you are observing is related to the small size of the room. Another possibility is that when the unit starts up after having shut itself off, it always starts up at high speed, and then shuts off again relatively soon. If that is true, it would appear to reflect some design or programming flaw. But this is rank speculation.
It would be interesting to hear what the tech people at Mitsubishi think. Have you called them?
Although exactly why it behaves this way is unclear, I'm pretty sure we can expect it to be more efficient running more smoothly at a lower level, so the external thermostat seems like a good idea all around--comfort, noise, efficiency...
This is a shockingly disappointing revelation. Mitsubishi should have told me I need to spend another $350 or more per unit to get decent control over its performance. This raises some important issues regarding the viability and reliability of the mini-split solution for heating and AC.
If Mitsubishi has any self-respect they will address this here in a public forum. Otherwise greenhorns will be snowed by employees protecting their company and my experience with tech support is that they usually don't know their products in real life application situations anyway.
Here is photographic guide and lots of chat re : DIY installation of the thermostat (scroll down the page to see it):
http://cleanenergywonk.com/2013/04/16/adding-a-programmable-thermostat-to-mitsubishi-mr-slim-heat-pumps/
$300 plus shipping from Amazon
http://www.amazon.com/Mitsubishi-MHK1/dp/B0057H146U
Your experience with the hand-held remote is pretty typical, based on my own experience at my house, plus others I've worked on with ductless mini-splits from 3-4 years ago. I've since switched to specifying external sensors/T-stats, for ductless as well as ducted mini-splits...mostly ducted for me these days in climate zone 4A, though.
Your lumpy graph is pretty typical of the "short cycling" that I see when my heat pump has reduced its output to its minimum, but is still overshooting (or thinks it's overshooting) the setpoint by "enough" to shut down the compressor. "Enough" is in quotes because the exact control logic is not published as far as I know.
I've found in my own house that I have to set the hand-held remote 3F-4F higher in winter and 3F-4F degrees lower in summer to achieve the room temperature I'm looking for. With more extreme temperatures, I have to increase the "offset". I suspect the infrared sensors that most of these systems come with (for the past several years) were/are an attempt to combat the effects of having a temperature sensor within inches of a heat exchange coil that is well over 120F in heating mode and under 50F in cooling mode.
See the attached IR image from a few minutes ago at my house. Room temperature is 68-69F...temperature on the wall just above the mini-split is 74F....temperature on the ceiling above the mini-split is ~72F on the right and ~78F on the left. What I'm seeing in this image is that there is a significant amount of heat conducted/radiated from the wall mount air handler UP to the adjacent wall and ceiling. I have to imagine the return air is warmed significantly before hitting the temperature sensor....don't know if the control logic is supposed to adjust for this effect, though.
Martin, we need a company rep expert to chime in.... and Dana, what say you?
Thanks for the thoughts all. It seems like using an external thermostat is a good idea all around.
Martin: I have not contacted anyone at Mitsubishi.
Flitch: I got my MHK1, new, for $140 shipped on ebay. I was debating about where to install the wireless receiver dongle when I realized there was enough space inside the circuit compartment of the heat pump itself... so I just shoved it in there. I was worried the shielding would prevent wireless communication, but it works fine. The compartment might be smaller on the smaller sized units though -- mine is 1.5 tons, so a little big. I'm sure if any tech ever needs to get in that compartment, they'll roll their eyes when they find it hiding in there, but hey... it works. I think the new FH models just changed their thermostat/network interface options.
Sensing the room temp at the wall coil input is bound to be pretty flaky compared to sensing it across the room out of the air current. Most mini-split installations I've seen first hand have poor absolute temperature control, even when they're running pretty evenly and keeping the room at a stable temp, but at a 2-5F difference from the setpoint. I've yet to deal with one that has short-cycling issues, but it has to be air-current related.
If an FH18 unit is set up to continuously change directions and is short cycling, try setting the louvers to a fixed direction and see if the behavior changes for the better. (And conversely.)
It's a bit ridiculous that the wall thermostat units are priced so high- there's no rocket science there. But the sales volumes are pretty low, since most of the time people seem OK with the remote control and intake-air temperature sensing, despite the temperature offset from the actual room temperature.
Dana, I disabled the side-to-side oscillation of the vanes because it makes a slightly annoying noise. But that's a good idea, I may play around with the airflow options to see if it makes a difference. For science.
I currently have it set to the "wide" horizontal mode, and the vertical mode is one of the upper settings, but not the highest one (blowing down lower dumps the hot air onto the kitchen table which is often not a good thing).
So Mitsubishi units only come with a wireless remote? I have two Fujitsus: a mini ceiling cassette and mini-ducted, and they both came with a full-featured wired thermostat. There's an obscure process described in a corner of the user manual that switches the temperature sensing from onboard the blower to the remote control, and I'm unsure why that's not the default setup. In any case, I'm quite happy with temperature control from the wired remote. Has anyone had similar trouble with the Fujitsus?
Still waiting for Misubishi to give us an explanation. I wonder if they realize how much business goes their way from this website.
Nick ... did you bid or buy posted price? Best posted price on the MHK1 these days is $200/unit.
Anyone know if there is a suitable, better priced alternative Tstat?
Interesting thread.
I just had an FE18NA installed and it has been making a funny noise- a continuously rising and falling tone like an engine with a broken governor. The contractor that installed it has verified that there is nothing obviously wrong and has run out of ideas to address the noise. I do not have the ability to measure electrical load vs time but it seems likely that I am seeing the same short cycling that the OP observed.
I too am seeing poor temperature regulation, although it seems that most of the time my unit runs over setpoint. Sometimes the room temperature is as much as 8 degrees high. This would not be a big deal to me except that the minimum setpoint is 59 degrees F so I sometimes end up heating to almost 70 degrees when I am not home and would prefer to keep the house at more like 50 (or even 45) degrees.
The setpoint error is understandable given the physical configuration but the short cycling is really troubling. A properly designed control system should not do this. Period.
I looks like I will be shelling out some more $$ for the external thermostat. Does anyone know if the external thermostat allows a lower setpoint temperature (vs 59 degrees minimum for FE18NA with internal thermostat) when used with the FE18NA ?
Chris: Of the handful of FE18s I've observed up-close I've never seen one exhibiting anything like that sort of behavior. If the contractor can't figure it out, it's time to get Mitsubishi tech support involved- there IS something wrong with it.
I have a similar problem. The unit is a PolarAC 12,000 mini split; Panasonic compressor private label.
The mini split powers down when the room reaches 18C no matter where the remote is set ( 75F or higher. We want the room at 20C.At 30F ambient the mini split will pull 6 amps without satisfying the thermostat. At -10F it pulls 11.6 A at 125 v.
The unit comes with a pigtail for an external thermostat but I have been told they are not yet available. Hopefully they will be before next winter.
Is an external thermostat the first thing I should try?
Thanks:
John
I've been fighting the set point issue for months now. I have a an FE18 and 12, and a GE9. All three blow past the set point up to 5* in heat mode. I'm pretty steady 3* over the set point until we get into the 60*s outside, then I start creeping towards the +5* over set point. It would be fine if I could simply do the math and adjust the set point accordingly, but the moment it drops below a certain outside temp, the units heat to the exact set point. So, if I adjust for a +5* set point and it dips to 35* outside I'm all of a sudden at 60-62* assuming a 70* target temp inside.
My HVAC company has been great. Mitsubishis- not so much. The HVAC co. had the NW Mitsubishi rep at my house and he found nothing wrong. He's basically dodging the issue.
I've started collecting MHK-1 units and plan to play hook them up and see what happens. If the set point issue is resolved I certainly hope my HVAC company will deal with Mitsubishi accordingly.
For what is supposed to be such a hi-tec, advanced system it sure has given me a lot of headaches and wasted time. +3-5* above the set point is Mickey Mouse. I could get better results with a store bought heat dish. Any info I can share, anything I can do to help anyone else, or whatever..... Feel free to email me. --->funny like ha ha at gmail dot com. <---
Matt,
Thanks very much for your comments. Once again, GBA is proving to be an invaluable resource for sharing information. We're all learning together here.
If the thing is running continuously and modulating the offset from the room temp is pretty stable over a range of outdoor temps, but it's not a fixed offset- it will vary by how well insulated your house is, the room's direct solar gain, etc..
When the load is low enough that they cycle on/off it can be all over the place, since the head only senses the indoor temp from the incoming air, and when the blower isn't running, it's sensing only the still air inside the cabinet. I suspect this is what's going on with Matt's units based on the behavior when it's over 60F outdoors. It's highly likely that the MHK-1 will fix the problem, as long as it's installed on an interior wall. out of the direct draft of the mini-split (or any other moving air.)
This isn't a Mitsubishi-specific problem, this behavior is true for all mini-splits that have the room temp sensor in the ductless head (which is the vast majority of them.) At least Mitsubishi has a wall-thermostat option- not all vendors do.
John's PolarAC-branded Panasonic sounds like there is something actually defective with the temperature sensing part of the controls. Depending on where the fault is in the control loop an external thermostat may or may not fix it.
Dana- What you are saying seems to make perfect sense. I have not monitored the system for the state of on/off so I can't say for sure the heads are actually turning off when the outdoor temps gets a bit warmer.
This might solve the question I've been asking myself--- 'why does the temp shoot higher in three different, sealed, rooms with three different handlers when the temps get above ~ 60* outside?'. I've turned off the units during these times of slightly higher outside temps, and, the indoor temps drop well below the set point so it's not the outside temps raising the inside temps. It is certainly the heating system.
Interesting. This just re-enforces the fact that these units are faulty. Maybe they are functioning as designed, but then the design is faulty.
A set point offset is one thing - I could live with that (even though it's kind of hokey). But not being able to have a consistent offset it absolutely unacceptable in my opinion. It stinks of cost cutting engineering. Sadly this seems to be the new American way.
I'm waiting on one more MHK-1 to pop up and I'll be ready to play around with my new 1000.00 Mitsubishi mini-split addition.
Until then I've been seeing what the system does in full auto mode. Not auto fan, auto heat/cool. Everyone tells me, and everything I read says don't run a multi-head system on auto heat/cool but aside from the obvious reasons it's suggested not to, there seems to be some real obvious reasons to do so. The real down side of this is it seems to take away the ability to have much of a set point difference in the various zones. I'd like to keep my gym @ 65*, my media room @ 65-67*, and my main living area at 70*.
However... for this little experiment I've set all temps to 68*, heat/cool auto, and fan auto. So far this darn thing is pretty steady at plus 2* from set point.
Another downside I've read about the auto heat/cool mode is that some people like to turn down the temps by several degrees (to save energy) when they leave the house for the day. In auto heat/cool mode this saves no energy at all, as the unit ramps up cool mode and then once the set point is reached it continues to run at the same energy consumption as if the person never turned the set point down in the first place.
I've read some debate about whether or not you're even saving energy when only turning down (or up depending on season) the set point for a typical day. The argument is these things are so efficient that it takes more energy to get the room heated (or cooled) back to your desired temperature vs. just letting it run at normal set point for the 8-10 hours a day you’re out of the house.
Anyways...... great discussion here. I'd love to hear more, and I will surely keep reporting back on my experience and outcome.
if I'm reading this right,
the OPs issues were that on heating, setting 70 resulted in [say] 65 actual, with a single head indoor/outdoor unit
Matt W is setting [say] 65 and getting 70 [under certain outside conditions]. with a multi head indoor/single outdoor unit
how does "multi head" impact individual head temp control?
would, say, a local cold spot, or a defective/ low reading at one of the multiheads, impact other units?
Mattw, have you tried running just one indoor unit at a time?
It is my understanding and experience that the individual handlers inside operating on one outdoor unit will only be impacted positively or negatively if the outdoor unit is working at or near max capacity. If the outdoor unit is sized properly turning one head on or off should have little if any impact on the others. At least when it comes to hitting target set points.
I've had the external thermostats installed for just under two weeks. Problem solved. They are exactly +2 degrees over the set point , but they maintain that two degrees regardless of outside temps. Mid 60's today, 36-37 a couple times since install. Anyone who has the thermostats installed and is getting dead nuts temps to the set point I'd be curious to now what happens if you go in to the settings and change the temp display offset of the thermostat to zero. I tried hoping it might change the actual temps, but it's just the display. How convenient for sly installers and Mitsubishi to allow the change of temp display to accommodate for their inaccurate, yet oddly precise, set point difference. Anyways.... external thermostats for the win. Big $$$ out of my pocket for the lose. But hey, I added the gateway so I could control it all from my phone. Only problem is the 'all' part is about 15% of what the actual remotes do. *rolls his eyes and goes off to enjoy his precise + 2* from set point heated home* :) Still happy to answer questions for anyone else having issues. It's been a 5 month haul for me and I finally feel complete. This thing better hold its own in the summer. :) :) funnylikehaha at gmail dot com is my email. I'm not notified of postings here FYI.
Hey Guy, I just bought a Mitsubishi Heat Pump and went ahead and purchased one of these mhk1 units. Is the consensus here that these are required for normal, ( non cycling ) operation?
Thanks
Alex
Most installations done with reasonable forethought and clearances from the mini-split head work just fine without it, from cycling point of view.
Since the room temp is sensed by the incoming air at the head, room air stratification and drafts can affect the accuracy of the setpoint setting relative to the average temperature in the room, just as placement of a wall thermostat in a less-than-ideal location can.
A common error is to place the head at the minimum allowed clearance from the ceiling, which is where the absolute warmest air will be from stratification at no/low air volumes through the head. When the blower kicks on or steps up it draws up cooler air from the room, and the sensed temperature drops rapidly. The unit responds to the rapidly falling sensed temp by stepping up even higher, potentially overshooting the setpoint, then stops. As the air in the room re-stratifies the average temp in the room can drop below the setpoint without being sensed. With more clearance from the ceiling & sides this type of cycling doesn't/shouldn't happen- it'll modulate bit around the setpoint, but won't be cycling on/off, even without a remote wall thermostat. Keeping it at least a foot below the ceiling would avoid the worst of the cycling scenarios. (Putting it nearer the floor would marginally improve heating efficiency & capacity too.)
Of course, oversizing the thing ridiculously for the load can result in cycling simply due to the oversizing factor and the limitations of it's modulating range.
For what it's worth, my minisplits (Fujitsu RLS3) seem to maintain air temps within a degree or less of the 68 degrees set at the remotes. I've been surprised at how consistent the indoor air temps are, regardless of outside temps. Of course we haven't had any real cold yet in Maine. Low so far is only 18 F.
chose* sorry.
I chose the placement of the units so I can't place the blame on the installers. However, with that said, I have two units ( with a third coming next year at some point) currently that are 9k under the max limit of my outside unit. I want to avoid the short cycling and keep the units on longer. The units seem to blow cold air at the end of each cycle which bothers the hell out of me. Will the thermostat accomplish this goal ?
Alex,
Probably not, based on your comment, but what mode do you have your Mitsubishi set on? Auto or Heat-only? If the temperature is above the point where it goes in heating-only mode, the mini-split might be shifting into AC mode, if you are running Auto.
I run Heat-only and adjust the vanes manually to near horizontal and slighly off vertical based on the recommendations from section 4.1 of this article:
http://apps1.eere.energy.gov/buildings/publications/pdfs/building_america/inverter-driven-heat-pumps-cold.pdf
We have been curious if an external thermostat would help, but we don't experience much short cycling except when the temperatures were closer to 50, and the initial start-up heat from the mini-split was too much for our insulated home.
We have two Mitsubishi heat pumps for our 1600 square foot metal SIP home: a 15K and 9K. So far, with temps around 25 as the low this year, only the 15K first floor unit has run. We have some air distribution issues, even though our plan is pretty open, but no real complaints. We have 67-68 in the living room, 66 in the bedroom off the living room, and 64-65 in a back utility room.
We have a cathedral ceiling, so rising heat was an issue. We found a used Airius fan on eBay, and it's worked well:
http://bit.ly/1NW9AKD
With it on the temperatures in the living room are 1-2 degrees higher. For a fan that draws 18 watts, that's a huge return. We have it mounted close to the peak of the ceiling and aim it down a back wall to create a circulatory effect in the living room.
I have the unit in heat mode, with Auto fan. I have thought about putting a circulation fan to push or pull air from floor but am not willing to spend 600 to get a destratification unit.
Sadness.
I used this information to diagnose my similar issue. i found with my Mitsubishi FH 15k btu unit that i was short cycling every 7 minutes. with temps set to 70 inside. The unit is installed on my second floor as the primary heat source for the addition. There is closed cell r38 foam on the ceiling and closed cell r28 on the walls. about 600 square ft living space. I know it was over sized since the heating contractor picked the unit assuming fiberglass insulation.
So to help with the issue i installed the wall mounted thermostat and find now it seems to run for about 30 min continuous and then tuns off for about an hour. What Im confused about is when i look at the energy readings it doesn't seem to be backing down when it gets close to temp, yet i see it ramping up in the beginning. Anyone have insight into the control scheme used? Maybe this is the correct behavior? outdoor temp right now with this behavior shown in the pictures is 27 degrees F
"I know it was over sized since the heating contractor picked the unit assuming fiberglass insulation."
The performance difference between R28 closed cell and R20 fiberglass in the walls or R38 ccSPF in the attic vs fiber is a lot less than the center-cavity performance would imply. The shorter thermal bridging path through the framing is an even more severe lower-R thermal short than with full-depth fiberglass, robbing the whole-assembly performance pretty substantially, despite the higher center-cavity R. The only real performance advantage that may have been lower air leakage, but even that is not guaranteed. At a 25% framing fraction the whole-wall R performance difference between 4.5" of R6.5/inch foam (R29), and R20 code min fiberglass at R5.5" is about R 0.6 (R15.75 whole wall vs. R15.15 whole wall.) They're essentially the same, and it would not affect the sizing of the heating equipment.
Typical 2x6/R20 type construction with an R38 fiberglass attic will usually come in at about 12 BTU/hr per square foot of conditioned space at 0F if reasonably tight, so for 600' of space you're probably looking at a heat load at 0F of 7200 BTU/hr, and a heat load at 27F of 4000 BTU/hr or less. With better than code windows & doors it could be under 3000 BTU/hr, and if one of the walls is a partition wall to other conditioned space it could even be under 2000 BTU/hr. A realistic heat load calculation would be necessary to know with any accuracy. If your picture is any indication, it looks like you don't have much R15.75 wall, due to the much higher R cathedralized ceiling, which means you're probably under 10 BTU/hr per foot @ 0F, and proportionally even less at +27F. (Proportional to a presumed 60F outdoor heating/cooling balance point temperature.)
The minimum modulated output of the FH15 at +47F is 5120 BTU/hr. The min-output at +27F isn't tested & specified in HSPF test, but it's probably over 4000 BTU/hr, and WAY over 2000 BTU/hr. It's highly likely that the reason it's still cycling even with the wall thermostat is that you don't have sufficient modulation range on the low end.
The FH09NA can modulate down to ~1600 BTU/hr @ +47F, and still delivers about 10,000 BTU/hr @ 0F, and probably would have been the far better choice here. This wasn't oversized by just a bit, it was upsized by a ridiculous 3-4x factor.
Unfortunately i agree with you that its way too much for the 2nd floor based on those numbers. having learned from this i know what it will be replaced with when the time comes. until then ill have to live with it from a heating perspective. From a cooling perspective being the the second floor i should be able to use it to cool the whole house by leaving the door to downstairs. here is more info after going down to 4 degrees last night. interestingly enough the air blowing out of the unit was definitely cooler but as you can see, no issues keeping the room between 72 and 73 degrees.
Any thoughts on the location choice for the thermostat? pics attached along with more about the insulation.
On a positive note i can open the window at any time to get fresh air and not worry about the room cooling down
i just thought of one thing. so its about 600 sq ft of living space but the knee walls as you can see are not insulated. the floor space is about 960sq ft counting the space in the knee walls. attached room design
Hi folks, wanted to chime in with my personal and yet anecdotal Mr Slim experience over the last 3 or so years.
They work great, no complaint at all, but I will certainly agree that due to cfm/airflow out of the units the exact temp on the remote is not the exact temp in the room. Not enough 'mixing', but nothing a simple desk or ceiling fan wouldn't fix. If you leave the vane moving options on this helps A LOT, but myself and most people seem to turn them off. I hate the random bzzmmm noise they make when they move.
I have been interested in the attachable thermostat and smart-phone integration due to a mysterious issue I have where when I come home from work I occasionally find everything has been turned up to 80F. Due to heat loss it can only make it up to 75 or 78 or so. This is unrelated to the strange summertime issue where I come home and the units are running in A/C mode, but the windows have mysteriously opened themselves. Curiously these issues only seems to happen when the lady of the house comes home early, but she always says she never saw anyone else in the house. Weird. If only these things had a programmable timer instead of just the ir remote would be my only true complaint against Mitsubishi as it is clearly their fault.
Rambling and mystery aside, I noticed that the MHK1 mitsubishi thermostat looks like a re-branded version of the Honeywell TH6320R1004 Wireless FocusPro that sells for thousands less. Weird right? Currently the mitsubishi MHK1 kit is $269 on amazon and there is one on ebay for $162 with 23 of you jokers bidding on it. The Honeywell kit is up for $170 on amazon. Yikes.
There is also a Mitsubishi PAC-US444CN-1 adapter that supposedly allows the M and P series to interface with Nest, Lyric, and other 3rd party smart thermostats instead of the more communist and proprietary sounding Redlink. Of course it is also about $250, but it shoul allow you mess with your minisplit thermostat settings with any regular programmable or online-enabled thermostat.
What always gets me is the price of all this home automation woo-woo. ~$100 for smartthings or redlink only hub, plus $250 for the adaptor/redlink thermostat, and then PLUS the non-redlink smart thermostat. We seem to be out $350 (plus $250 per additional indoor unit) if you go with redlink, and that plus the cost of a google Nest or other $200 smart enabled thermostat for the non-redlinkers.
For $500 I should probably start on the siding or crawlspace work for better payback. Figuring out who keeps opening the windows is only questionably worth it.
-Q
I've having the same issue as Pierre above - I have three split Mitsubishi heads - one high mount, two low-wall. All are in small rooms, but the issue is that in heat mode, everything set to manual, TStat set to 59, they all heat much higher - 70+ degrees. Usually about 73-74 with outside temp in the 50s. Regardless of where the unit is reading the temp from, it's crazy to me that it's reading would be THAT far off. Gonna have to get the external, $300/each MHK1, but I'd really like to either not spend $1,000 on this, or at least know that will 100% fix the problem. With the minimum 59 degree set point, I can't tell if it's just calibrated wildly wrong or if something else is going on.
I'm having the same issue as above but my MSZ HE-18NA doesn't work with the MHK1. I bought one thinking it would but there isn't a connector soldered on the PCB where it says CN105. Has anyone tried soldering the MHK1 onto the pins marked that?
My thermostat has also been known to suddenly change its setpoint temperature mysteriously.
I used the schedule function to reset the temperature every few hours during the day. The constant electronic watchdog rendered the interference futile :}
The MHK1 appears to be able to support a setback schedule - just use the same temp for each time period.
I have been running an FE12NA (1st floor) and FE09NA (2nd floor) for the past two years in my high performance house. Both units work well, no MHK1. 2 questions: What is the difference between running units on auto with a set point versus a set point with a fan speed. Is there any modulation and monitoring function with set point * and fan speed approach or it is just delivering a constant stream of 68* air at fan speed 1-2-3? Major difference in energy usage?
Also, a previous comment was made about Fuji's having Tstat function in the hand remote or head unit (selectable). Is this feature on Mitsu FE-NA series?
The FE12 is never delivering a stream of 68F air (unless you normally keep it at 45F or cooler indoors :-) ). If you keep it at 68-70F indoors, it's delivering 110-130F air most of the time, might deliver 95F air at max blower speed when it's 5F or lower outdoors. See the bench test results in Table 6 on page 28 of the appendix (p36 in PDF pagination) here:
http://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy11osti/52175.pdf
Resurrecting a fairly old thread...
I am noticing the same thing with my mini split and pondering installing the MHK1 or go the Kumo Cloud route: the Wifi adaptor+bluetooth temperature sensors.
Anybody have any experience with the later option ?
Resurrecting this thread once again because I am having similar problems with my new Mitsubishi system and MRCH1s did not solve it. I have 5 heads and MRCH1s on each. I am still having a problem of overshoot and its different for each room.
Basement Wall Unit – 4 degrees higher than the set temperature
Bedroom 1 Ceiling Cassette - 5 degrees higher than the set temperature
Bedroom 2 Ceiling Cassette - 8 degrees higher than the set temperature
Bedroom 3 Ceiling Cassette - 3 degrees higher than the set temperature
Living Room 4 way cassette - 3 degrees higher than the set temperature
I have used option 173 on each unit set to 1 to have my remotes used for sensing temperature.
I also have problem with my remotes not being able to control fan speed. The fans are perpetually on low no matter what setting I have on the remote.
I have found Mitsubishi Support people generally nice but not very knowledgeable. They seem to only have the same documentation that I do. I've called multiple times and gotten different answers each time.
Sometimes the overshoot is due to refrigerant bleed on multi split systems. The outdoor unit can only turn down so far, so it bleeds a bit of flow thru satisfied units. If the outdoor unit is oversized too drastically this can lead to overheating.
One fix is the fan off when satisfied setting. You may be able to do this as an installer option on some indoor units, and some require actually snipping a small jumper on the circuit board.
Another fix has it's own downsides, run the fans at a higher speed so when they heat they can take the full minimum capacity and not require any bleed flow. This will cause more cycling though. At low fan speed a 9000btu head may only put out maybe 3000-4000btu/hr, if the compressor minimum is 12-14kbtu, then you end up overheating the other spaces. At higher fan speed there is much less left over capacity to distribute to satisfied zones.
The best fix is a smaller outdoor unit and a ducted unit serving several bedrooms.
I have a single FH09 and putting the MHK1 on has been a game changer. It maintained temperature ok previously but I could hear the compressor changing it's speed constantly (Shouldn't have bolted to a bedroom brick wall). With the MHK1 it runs steadily at the same speed, the the space temp fluctuates much less than when it uses the internal sensor. It's much more noticeable in heating mode than cooling mode.
Thanks. I'm happy one of the options is the " fan off when satisfied setting" since I was planning to do this anyhow for comfort reasons. We don't really like the unit blowing cool feeling air once its up to temperature.
I'm not sure how to run higher fan speeds since I have not been able to control fan speed from the MRCH1 controller even though that is a selectable option.
My overshoot got fixed by a technician that changed the board to disable fan when temp is met. I think you can desolder a resistor to the same effect.
From what I gather there is always a minimum 30% refrigerant flowing through. That in a small room made it heat way too much.
Sounds good. I'll try that for sure.
My 4-way unit already allowed me to program the fan off from the remote but it still overshoots by 3 degrees. I guess that could be spill over from the other rooms.
This has been a great thread to read. I apologize up front for the long post.
I'm in a newly constructed 3 story townhouse, ~1700 soft with interior dimensions 13’7” x 42’4”. I have 5 Mitsubishi MSZ-GL09NA indoor units each with a Mitsubishi Kumo Cloud Wi-Fi Adapter PAC-USWHS002-WF-2. I have one minisplit in each bedroom (first and second floors, situated at the ends of the house) and one on each end of the open top floor containing living, dining, kitchen areas. The 3rd floor ceiling is slanted from ~9' on the kitchen end to ~14' on the living room end. Floor to ceiling south facing windows are in the living room. A hallway and staircase occupy the center of the home on floors 1 and 2.
I have a single MXZ-5C42NA2 outdoor unit (no branch box, not hyper heat).
I'm having a heck of a time getting the 5 units to keep their respective spaces at their set temperatures. Ideally I'd set a min and max temp for each space, set the units to Auto mode, Auto Fan, Auto vane, and then rarely touch the settings again.
I added the WiFi adapters hoping the "cloud" would solve my problem. It hasn't.
This is my first winter in the house, and the first season I've used heat mode. I find the upstairs will heat to higher than the max set temperature, while the lower rooms will drop well below their min set temp. The upstairs heat is exacerbated when the sun is low enough to come under the overhang of the living room windows. I understand that the system can't heat and cool at the same time, though I expected in Auto mode the upstairs units would cool until the temp was met, then go back to heating the other spaces if needed. With a temp range set to 66-72 for all spaces, the upstairs will get as hot as 78 (before I open a window or two) and the first floor bedroom (with the door to the hallway open) will drop to 62.
I often find the units unresponsive to a change in settings via the Kumo Cloud app. I end up turning off all units, then 10 minutes later I'll turn on the unit for the space I'm occupying to get the proper set temperature.
Per Mitsubishi tech support, I've included all units in a single crossover group, and set Thermal Fan Off to "stop in heat and cool."
With information from this thread, I'm considering adding remote thermometers like the Mitsubishi PAC-USWHS003-TH-1 to each unit. It sounds from the collective experience that this should help. I'm not super hopeful it will, and expect I have a larger stratification problem.
What are your recommendations? I didn't get the impression that the installer was super knowledgeable with the wireless dongles and Kumo Cloud when they worked on my neighbor's home. I'm a little reluctant to go back to them right now for a fix.
Thanks!
You are describing exactly my issue:
I had 3 mini splits ( 2 in rooms that were a bit small for the size of the unit )
The small rooms were constantly cooking whenever the other unit was drawing ‘juice’.
What I learned is that there is a minimum flow when an item is shut off of about 20-30%. That coupled with the fact that the fan is always blowing slightly ( to sense temperature ) by default caused the units to overshoot in standby.
The ‘fix’ was to have a technician replace one of the boards to cut the fan when temperature is attained (new board I think it only has a removed resistor) This sorta fixed the overshooting albeit the cooling now feels a bit ‘muggy’.
I tried changing the fan setting in the kumo setting but it never seems to save the setting :(
Hope this helps.
Thanks clusty. This does help. I've set the Thermal Off for heat and cool. I think this shuts down the fan to prevent the "overshooting" you mentioned. I'm going to add remote thermometers and see how that changes things.